The South China Sea (SCS) is an important water body for international trade. It connects the East Asian states with Europe and the rest of the world for trade and energy supplies. The South China Sea is crucial for Japan, China, the Philippines, and other ASEAN states for their economic growth. China is the state with the most advanced military, the highest economic growth, and ambition of regional hegemony, and it is militarily active in the South China Sea.
China has invested around $50 billion in the construction of artificial islands and equipping them with military capabilities. These Chinese claims and actions threaten the interests of ASEAN states in the South China Sea. China argues that its actions are legitimate by emphasizing its ‘nine-dash line’ on maps and historical ties to the region. This assertiveness of China in the South China Sea is against international law and has serious implications for regional stability and global trade.
The South China Sea is strategically very significant with $3.4 trillion (USD) worth in trade passes through it annually. The South China Sea is rich in fisheries which is the livelihood of millions of people in neighboring states. The sea also holds 11 billion barrels of oil and 190 trillion cubic feet of natural gas. These resources are the center of conflict between states.
China has converted submerged reefs into artificial islands and deployed military assets necessary for defensive and offensive purposes. This posture of China is a high point of concern for the USA because of its security pacts and agreements with Japan (QUAD), Taiwan (Mutual Defense Treaty), and the Philippines. The other states in the region like Vietnam, Indonesia, Malaysia, Brunei and the Philippines also have claims over these islands and cite the United Nations Convention on the Law of Seas (UNCLOS) due to violations of their Exclusive Economic Zones (EEZs) by China.
There are many tiny reefs in the South China Sea scattered in distances. According to the Asia Times report, China has transformed seven reefs in the Spratlys into artificial islands. The distinctive method involves extracting coral from the reef core, pulverizing it, and piling it up to create elevated land to host various facilities. According to Asian Times, these include China’s three largest artificial islands, Mischief Reef, Fiery Cross Reef, and Subi Reef, which create a triangular defense position against US bases located in the Philippines. These islands have military capabilities including radar systems, anti-ship and anti-aircraft missiles, fighter jets, surface-to-air missiles, airstrips, communication arrays, and naval berths. This provides China with an edge to control and show its power in the sea. Vietnam and The Philippines also have claims to the reefs and islands within their EEZs and territorial waters.
This brings the legal Framework in this dispute defined by UNCLOS. The UNCLOS defines that 200 nautical miles from the state coastline are state’s EEZs and have rights over resources in their respective EEZs. But China’s actions near the Philippines and Vietnam EEZs are violating the provisions of UNCLOS. The Philippines filed a case against China in the Permanent Court of Arbitration (PCA) for violating the UNCLOS. The 2016 PCA ruling invalidated China’s territorial claims, declaring them inconsistent with international law and norms. Beijing dismissed the ruling as null and void by citing the ‘nine-dash line’ asserting historical control over the region based on ancient maps and records.
These actions by China threaten the stability of the region. The ASEAN states have sought diplomatic solutions, but China’s economic influence over certain member-states (Laos and Cambodia) has hindered any progress. The Philippines and Vietnam are increasing their military and defense capabilities by joining alliances with the US and Australia. The presence of US bases in the Philippines and Taiwan involved the risk of global conflict over the South China Sea.
Since 2020, the US has conducted several Freedom of Navigation Operations (FONOPs) in the South China Sea, sailing warships through disputed waters to challenge China’s excessive claims. In March 2023, The USS Milius operated near the Paracel Islands, the region claimed by China, Vietnam, and Taiwan. The US conducts FONOPs to affirm the principles of international law under the provisions of UNCLOS. China protests against these FONOPs, accusing the US of violating its sovereignty. This poses the risks of clashes, which can escalate and lead to global conflict. These interactions are complex and can cause conflict due to misunderstandings between the USA and China.
China hold ambitions to dominate the region by militarizing the artificial islands. However, this poses certain risks towards regional stability due to non-adherence to international law. To overcome the risk of global conflict between China and USA, the global community must prioritize multilateral dialogue to avoid any misunderstandings. All states including China and ASEAN must comply with legal frameworks, like UNCLOS to ensure peace and security in the South China Sea. The tensions in the South China Sea are stark reminders of the dangers of unchecked geopolitical rivalries.
Be the first to comment